So, I’ve decided I may have dived in a bit early with my last post. I started doing some research, and found that, not only do I come across images of the alignment grid… they’re all over the place. This is a thought experiment that we are by no means the first to experiment with. So, the question becomes, should we pursue it?
Or do we pursue the white whales?
In what has been called “the nerdiest debate,” a lot of people have made grids like the one above. One way of thinking of the alignments is to group characters variously into the roles they seem to follow, and stick to that. Another is to group characters by alignment within a single work or world of fiction, so that you can judge characters as being more lawful or chaotic than each other, or more good or evil than each other. I found this great one for Game of Thrones, for instance:
Now, I think that the nine alignments are one of the better overall thoughts out there in philosophy, because they give a more solid way to understand good and evil. They create a graph, basically, with axes of law->chaos, and good->evil. In fiction, and especially speculative fiction, we explore the concepts of good and evil, of people and the things they will do in a given situation. This is a scientific approach to understanding that and quantifying that; not a bad thing, right?
However, I was starting to plan on spending several months, one a week, exploring alignments, and blah blah blah. It’s been done. Instead, let me condense that down to one post here where I include some of my favorite thoughts on the subject, all in the form of one of those graphics!
Sorry, I’m pretty new to photo editing, but that’s not entirely the point, right?
My plan now is to focus in on some specific characters who are harder to nail down, and see if we can decide on what they really mean in the world. That sounds more interesting, right?
Not the only ones thinking about the Borg right now… http://io9.com/5985124/is-it-possible-that-the-borg-are-the-perfect-enemy
LikeLike
Pingback: The first question! Hidden in plain sight! “Doctor Who?” – A Character Study | Comparative Geeks
Pingback: Not the son Tywin Lannister needs, but the son Tywin Lannister deserves – A Character Study of Tyrion Lannister | Comparative Geeks
Pingback: Time for a Rebuild | DBCII
Pingback: Something About This Worked | DBCII
Pingback: Something About This Worked – Part 2 | DBCII
Pingback: 6-Month Anniversary – Top 5 Posts So Far! | Comparative Geeks
Pingback: The Nine Alignments of Batman | Comparative Geeks
Pingback: What Would You Like to See an Alignment Grid of? | Comparative Geeks
Pingback: The Nine Alignments of Guardians of the Galaxy | Comparative Geeks